O Brother Where Art Thou And The Odyssey Comparison Essay

O Brother Where Art Thou And The Odyssey Comparison Essay-87
What does it mean to take a piece of literature and put it onto film?Is it appropriate for the filmmaker to make changes, or must he or she tell the story exactly as written?Since this work was originally penned nearly three thousand years ago, many others have taken up the story and use it as a foundation for new renditions.

What does it mean to take a piece of literature and put it onto film?Is it appropriate for the filmmaker to make changes, or must he or she tell the story exactly as written?Since this work was originally penned nearly three thousand years ago, many others have taken up the story and use it as a foundation for new renditions.

While the basic story can be reduced to a few sentences, Homer utilized over 12,000 metered lines to flesh out the story, while the Coen Brothers used approximately an hour and forty-five minutes of screen time.

The details that make up the bulk of each work demonstrate the similarities and differences in structure, focus, and storytelling approach.

Time and time again Everett displayed Odysseus-like quality.

Even in the end when returned to his hometown town in after finding out his wife was preparing to remarry, he disguised himself as an old man.

In the Odyssey, Penelope was the one thing that fueled Odysseus's journey home, t...

Editor’s Note: This is a comparison between the ancient epic, The Odyssey and the modern film O Brother, Where Art Thou?Tumultuous experiences, terrible odds, and horrifying foes confront the protagonist, who must overcome them all, in order to successfully complete the journey.One of the iconic examples of this archetype is Homer’s .Many of those opposing characters are transferred from Homer to the Coens’ version, but they are usually adapted to fit the context of the film.In essence, this story serves as a case study for what Robert Stam refers to as fidelity between film and novel (or written work).Therefore, it is appropriate to consider the elements that are inherent in film and novel, and how those can, or cannot, be transferred from one to the other.Using examples from both stories, the method of storytelling, and the benefits and advantages of each can be made evident.Both versions show the protagonist struggling to reach home in order to save his family.Both allow for supernatural elements to oppose, or at times to support, the hero on his journey.I also think the role of the blind prophet might be a symbolization of Athena, and how she took another form to disguise herself, but yet help lead Odysseus in the correct direction.Observing the characters, one could easily assume that George Clooney's character, Ulysses Everett Mc Gill, seems to be the representation of Odysseus, on a journey to return home to his wife, whom is at risk of remarrying.

SHOW COMMENTS

Comments O Brother Where Art Thou And The Odyssey Comparison Essay

  • The Odyssey, and O Brother, Where Art Thou compare and.
    Reply

    Transcript of The Odyssey, and O Brother, Where Art Thou compare and contrast. The Odyssey- Odysseus meets Teireseus- a former seer and shade from the underworld. O Brother, Where Art Thou- Everett, Pete, and Delmar meet the blind man on the railroad. Both journey back to their families.…

  • FREE Odyssey vs. O Brother. Essay -
    Reply

    In the year 2000, the movie, O Brother Where Art Thou, was released as an adaptation of Homer's classic novel The Odyssey. Even though O Brother Where Art Thou is not a complete reincarnation of the original masterpiece, there are still a vast amount of similarities between the two works of art.…

  • A Comparison on Homer and O Brother Where Art Thou - Essay
    Reply

    Read this History Other Essay and over 89,000 other research documents. A Comparison on Homer and O Brother Where Art Thou. A Comparison on Homer and O Brother Where Art Thou In Homer, the main character's name is Odysseus.…

  • Free essay on Odyssey And O Brother Where Art Thou Compared.
    Reply

    In fact, one critic notes, “O Brother Where Art Thou?” is a Homeric journey through Mississippi during the Depression.”Ebert p 1 Thus, we find the modern film depiction of the troubles of a man during the depression is molded by the ancient struggles of Odysseus in Homer’s Odyssey.…

  • The Odyssey and O Brother Where Art Thou Comparison
    Reply

    The Coen brothers' O Brother Where Art Thou? Is more understandable and is slightly different from the books moral sense. I will be discussing the similarities and the differences between both of these epics. The first comparison I noticed in the film was the blind man on the railroad tracks, which is the blind prophet in the Odyssey.…

  • A Comparison of The Odyssey and the Movie O' Brother, Where.
    Reply

    A Comparison of The Odyssey and the Movie O' Brother, Where Art Thou PAGES 2. WORDS 687. View Full Essay. About this essay. Reading example essays works the same way!…

  • Comparing and contrasting Odyssey by Homer to movie O'Brother.
    Reply

    Extract of sample "Comparing and contrasting Odyssey by Homer to movie O'Brother, Where Art Thou" Download file to see previous pages works of art, several characters in the film have names similar to the characters in Homer’s work and the protagonist in the film, Ulysses Everett McGill, shares his name with the protagonist in Odyssey, i.e.…

  • Kelly's Blog The Odyssey and O Brother, Where Art Thou.
    Reply

    O Brother, Where Art Thou. an Oscar nominated film made in 2000, is a modern interpretation of the novel The Odyssey, written by Homer in ancient Greece around 1000 BC. In both The Odyssey and O Brother, Where Art Thou? the main characters, Odysseus and Everett, have women in their lives that deeply influence them. Odysseus’ wife, Penelope, and Everett’s wife, Penny, are comparable characters.…

The Latest from vizitt.ru ©